Cycling vs. running: Which is better for weight loss?

Aerobic exercises are now crucial components of fitness routines. Among these, cycling and running stand out as popular choices due to their accessibility, versatility, and potential to burn calories effectively. 

The age-old debate of cycling vs. running for weight loss has sparked numerous discussions and opinions, each championing its benefits. As individuals seek the most efficient and enjoyable path to shed excess pounds, it’s essential to understand the unique advantages and considerations of each activity.

How does the weight loss work?

Before delving into the comparison between cycling and running for weight loss, it’s essential to establish a foundational understanding of the principles that govern the process. 

Weight loss occurs when the body expends more calories than it consumes, resulting in a deficit that prompts using stored fat for energy. This fundamental concept highlights the significance of calorie management in achieving and sustaining weight loss goals.

Caloric intake and expenditure form the cornerstone of weight management [1]. When you consume more calories than your body expends, the excess energy is stored as fat, contributing to weight gain. 

Conversely, creating a calorie deficit through a combination of reduced caloric intake and increased physical activity leads to weight loss.

Featured product offer
PhenGold Multi-Action Weight Loss Formula
  • Packed with clinically proven ingredients, like Green Tea, L-Theanine, and Cayenne Pepper, all known for their fat-burning properties.
  • FDA registered and GMP certified. Suitable for vegetarian and vegan diets. Free from soy, gluten, and dairy, and contains no GMO ingredients or artificial fillers.
  • 100% safe and natural, with no side effects.

What can cycling do to your body?

Cycling presents a compelling option for individuals seeking an effective and enjoyable way to promote weight loss and overall fitness. This section explores the multifaceted advantages of cycling, ranging from its physical demands to its psychological benefits.

Physical demands and mechanics

One of the standout features of cycling is its low-impact nature, making it a particularly attractive choice for individuals with joint sensitivities or those recovering from injuries. 

The circular pedaling motion minimizes the impact on joints, reducing the risk of strains or stress-related injuries that can be associated with higher-impact activities.

Caloric expenditure

Calories burned during cycling can vary based on factors such as speed, terrain, and resistance level [2]. 

On average, a moderate-paced cycling session can burn a significant number of calories. For instance, an hour of cycling at a moderate intensity can lead to caloric expenditure ranging from 400 to 600 calories, depending on these variables.

Long-distance and endurance

Cycling has gained popularity as a sport for long-distance and endurance challenges. This aspect is particularly beneficial for individuals aiming to burn calories and gradually enhance their stamina. 

Longer rides engage the body’s aerobic system, promoting fat oxidation and contributing to weight loss efforts.

Long-distance and endurance

Joint health and injury risk

Cycling’s low-impact nature benefits joint health and reduces the likelihood of overuse injuries. 

Unlike running, where repetitive impact can stress joints and lead to issues, cycling offers a gentler option for consistent exercise without excessive strain on the body’s weight-bearing structures.

Psychological aspects

Beyond its physical benefits, cycling offers positive effects on mental well-being. Outdoor cycling, in particular, provides exposure to nature and fresh air, which can alleviate stress and boost mood. 

The rhythmic motion of pedaling can have a calming effect, making cycling an effective stress-relief activity.

What are the benefits of running?

Running, a high-impact aerobic exercise, has garnered popularity as a go-to option for weight loss and cardiovascular fitness. 

Beyond its calorie-burning potential, running offers a host of benefits that contribute to overall health and well-being.

Cardiovascular intensity

Running is a vigorous cardiovascular workout that elevates heart rate and oxygen consumption, effectively improving cardiovascular health. 

Engaging in regular running sessions can enhance the efficiency of the heart, strengthen blood vessels, and promote circulation. The sustained elevated heart rate during running helps burn calories efficiently, aiding in weight loss efforts.

Caloric burn and intensity

Running ranks among the most effective calorie-burning exercises. The energy expenditure during a run can be substantial, making it an appealing choice for those aiming to shed excess weight.

The intensity of running, coupled with its impact on metabolism, can lead to the continued burning of calories even after the workout is complete, a phenomenon known as the “afterburn” effect.

Bone density and strength

The weight-bearing nature of running exerts stress on bones, promoting the development of bone density and strength. This aspect is particularly advantageous for individuals concerned about bone health and susceptibility to osteoporosis. 

Strong bones are essential for overall well-being and can contribute to weight management by supporting a more active lifestyle.

HIIT and metabolism

Running can incorporate High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT), a training method involving alternating between periods of high-intensity effort and recovery [3]. 

HIIT has been shown to effectively boost metabolism and enhance fat loss. Integrating HIIT into running routines allows for efficient calorie burning and can break through weight loss plateaus.

Featured product offer
Xwerks Motion
  • Contains a synergistic blend of cluster dextrin carbohydrates, BCAA's (Branched-Chain Amino Acids), and electrolytes.
  • 30 servings per bag; each serving contains 25g of carbohydrates.
  • Cluster dextrin for high molecular weight, exceptional solubility, and minimal osmotic pressure.

Mental well-being

Beyond its physical benefits, running also positively impacts mental health. The release of endorphins during a run contributes to an improved mood, reduced stress levels, and increased feelings of well-being. 

Running provides a meditative escape and an avenue to clear one’s mind, making it a powerful tool for managing stress and anxiety—a crucial aspect of any weight loss journey.

What are the factors that influence your choices?

The decision to opt for cycling or running in your weight loss journey hinges on a multitude of factors that encompass personal preferences, physical considerations, and practical aspects. 

Understanding these factors will guide you in selecting the activity that aligns with your goals and lifestyle.

Personal preferences

The enjoyment derived from an activity plays a pivotal role in its sustainability. Consider whether you find more pleasure in the wind in your hair as you cycle or the rhythm of your footsteps while running. 

Selecting an activity that resonates with you increases the likelihood of consistency, enhancing the effectiveness of your weight loss efforts.

Impact on muscle mass

Weight loss isn’t solely about shedding pounds; it’s also about preserving lean muscle mass.

Cycling and running have distinct effects on muscle engagement. Cycling predominantly targets the lower body muscles, while running engages a broader range of muscles, including those in the upper body. 

Balancing cardiovascular exercises with strength training can help prevent muscle loss and promote a toned physique.

Time efficiency

Your daily routine and time constraints play a significant role in determining the feasibility of incorporating cycling or running. 

Running tends to require less time, as it can be done without the need for special equipment or a designated route. Cycling may demand more time due to equipment setup, route planning, and the potential for longer distances.

Accessibility and cost

Both cycling and running have differing accessibility requirements. Running can be done virtually anywhere, necessitating only a comfortable pair of shoes.

On the other hand, cycling may involve purchasing a bicycle and related gear, as well as identifying suitable cycling routes. 

Health and physical considerations

Your current health status and any existing physical conditions should influence your choice between cycling and running. 

Cycling’s low-impact nature may be more suitable for individuals with joint issues, while running’s weight-bearing impact might be beneficial for bone health. 

Consult with medical professionals to ensure that your chosen activity aligns with your physical well-being.

Can I mix cycling and running?

The integration of cycling and running within your fitness routine can yield many benefits that enhance weight loss, overall fitness, and enjoyment. 

Cross-training—alternating between cycling and running—offers a well-rounded approach that leverages the strengths of both activities.

Muscular diversity

Cycling and running engage different muscle groups. Cycling primarily targets the quadriceps, hamstrings, and glutes, while running involves muscles in the lower body, core, and upper body to a certain extent. 

By incorporating both activities, you can achieve a more balanced development of muscles throughout your body.

Cardiovascular conditioning

Combining cycling and running contributes to diverse cardiovascular conditioning [4]. 

Cycling emphasizes endurance and aerobic capacity, while running enhances cardiovascular fitness and burns calories effectively. This synergy results in improved overall cardiovascular health and can accelerate weight loss progress.

Cardiovascular conditioning

Injury prevention

One of the advantages of cross-training is its potential to reduce the risk of overuse injuries. 

Cycling’s low-impact nature can provide respite for joints stressed by running, allowing them to recover while still maintaining cardiovascular activity. By alternating between the two activities, you give specific muscle groups and joints periodic recovery time.

Preventing plateaus

Weight loss plateaus can be frustrating and demotivating. Combining cycling and running introduces variety into your routine, challenging your body in different ways. This variability prevents your body from adapting too quickly, encouraging continuous progress and overcoming stagnation in your weight loss journey.

Mental stimulation

Monotony can hamper consistency in fitness routines. By incorporating both cycling and running, you introduce diversity that keeps your workouts interesting and mentally engaging. 

The excitement of switching between activities can sustain your motivation and enthusiasm over the long term.

Closing thoughts

The choice between cycling and running is not a one-size-fits-all decision. Both activities offer distinct advantages that can contribute to your journey towards a healthier, fitter you. 

Cycling, with its low-impact nature and diverse range of benefits, stands as an appealing option, while running’s cardiovascular intensity, calorie burn, and mental well-being benefits hold their own allure.

FAQs

Which burns more calories, cycling or running?

Both cycling and running can burn significant calories, but the exact amount depends on factors such as intensity, duration, and individual factors. Running tends to burn calories more quickly due to its higher impact and greater cardiovascular demands.

Can I lose weight by only cycling or running, or is a combination better?

Both cycling and running have weight loss benefits, but combining them can offer a more well-rounded approach. Cross-training helps prevent plateaus, engages different muscle groups, and reduces the risk of overuse injuries.

Is running bad for my knees compared to cycling?

Running does involve impact on joints, which may raise concerns for some individuals. Cycling is a low-impact activity that places less stress on the knees.

Featured product offer
Future Kind+ Vegan Organic Apple Cider Vinegar Weight Loss Gummies
  • 60 chewable gummies in each container.
  • Has the power of apple cider vinegar to support healthy digestion and weight management.
  • Free from GMOs, gluten, wheat, yeast, soy, and animal derivatives.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5726407/
[2] https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/calories-burned-biking
[3] https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/high-intensity-interval-training/
[4] https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/healthyliving/cycling-health-benefits

The information included in this article is for informational purposes only. The purpose of this webpage is to promote broad consumer understanding and knowledge of various health topics. It is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health care provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or treatment and before undertaking a new health care regimen, and never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.