Is creatine right for you? Understanding the pros and cons

Creatine often buzzes around health and fitness circles, and you’ve likely heard a friend or a trainer mention it. So, what’s the fuss about?

Naturally found in our muscles and foods like red meat and fish, creatine is a compound that plays a pivotal role in high-intensity, short-duration activities.

Think of that quick sprint or that heavy lift at the gym – creatine’s got a hand in powering those.

We will break down the science-backed pros and tangible cons, helping you make an informed decision.

Whether you’re an athlete eyeing that extra edge or just someone curious about popular supplements, understanding creatine’s role can be a game-changer.

Featured product offer
Perpetua.Life Creatine Monohydrate Gummy Bears Low-Sugar
  • Contains 4 g of creatine monohydrate.
  • Tropical flavored gummies contain only 1 g sugar.
  • Sourced and manufactured in the US.

What are the pros of creatine?

Creatine has taken the fitness and health community by storm. Why? Because when it comes to boosting athletic performance and promoting muscle growth, creatine often finds itself in the limelight [1].

Let’s explore why many see it as their go-to supplement and if it might just be what you’ve been looking for.

1. Enhanced exercise performance

Creatine plays a starring role in our body’s energy systems. When you’re pushing hard in a sprint or lifting heavy weights, your body relies on a specific energy currency: ATP (adenosine triphosphate). Creatine helps replenish this energy source more rapidly, meaning:

  • Helps replenish energy faster during short, high-intensity activities.
  • Boosts your overall stamina and reduces fatigue between sets.
  • Elevates recovery speed after vigorous exercises.

If you’re eyeing that extra rep or shaving a few seconds off your sprint time, adding creatine to your regimen might give you the edge you’re after. It’s like a silent partner, helping you perform at your peak without the fanfare.

2. Muscle mass increase

Dreaming of stronger, more defined muscles? Creatine might just be the ticket. This power-packed supplement supports your muscles in a few key ways:

  • Draws water into muscle cells, making them appear larger and aiding in muscle growth.
  • Increases levels of proteins that drive muscle growth.
  • Enhances cell signaling, which aids in muscle repair and new muscle development.

All these factors work together to not only give your muscles a fuller appearance but also contribute to genuine muscle growth over time. So, if building muscle is on your fitness to-do list, giving creatine a go could be a wise move.

muscle mass increase

3. Brain health benefits

While muscles often steal the show when talking about creatine, your brain shouldn’t be left out of the conversation [2]. The brain demands a lot of energy, and just like with muscles, creatine can come to the rescue:

  • Provides much-needed energy for the brain, especially during tasks demanding mental agility.
  • Shows promise in protecting against some neurological diseases.
  • Helps reduce brain fatigue, keeping you mentally sharp even after strenuous activities.

Brainpower is as vital as physical strength, and ensuring it stays in top form is essential. With creatine’s potential benefits, you’re not just supporting your muscles but also giving your cognitive functions a leg up. 

4. Safety profile

Safety is paramount, especially when considering a new supplement. Fortunately, creatine scores high marks here. Key points to note:

  • Most studies find no major side effects for healthy individuals taking recommended dosages.
  • Long-term use has been studied extensively, with minimal concerns surfacing.
  • Always best to consult a healthcare professional, especially if pre-existing health conditions are at play.

Creatine has established itself as a trusted ally in the fitness world. When used responsibly, it stands as one of the safer supplements available.

But, as with anything, moderation and proper guidance can ensure you reap its benefits without setbacks.

5. Other potential benefits

Creatine’s benefits stretch beyond just muscles and brain health. Let’s take a quick glance at some other potential perks:

  • Bone health: Some studies suggest creatine might support bone regeneration.
  • Blood sugar management: There’s evidence indicating better glucose transportation with creatine, which can be great for blood sugar levels.
  • Muscle comfort: A few users have noted fewer muscle cramps and strains with creatine use.

To sum it up, creatine has more to offer than meets the eye. From supporting athletic prowess to potentially sharpening our cognitive edge, its benefits are as varied as they are impressive.

If you’re looking to elevate your fitness game or simply ensure your body and mind are operating at peak performance, understanding and considering creatine’s role could make all the difference.

What are the cons of creatine?

As with many things in life, creatine comes with its highs and lows. While its benefits are often celebrated in fitness circles, it’s only fair to discuss some of its potential downsides [3]. Knowledge is power, and understanding both sides of the coin will help you make an informed choice.

1. Water weight gain

One of the immediate effects that many users notice upon starting creatine is weight gain. This isn’t fat but rather water.

Creatine increases water content in muscle cells. Though this can lead to muscles appearing larger, it might be unsettling if you’re not anticipating the scale to tip a bit.

  • Creatine pulls water into your muscles, resulting in a quick weight gain.
  • This isn’t fat, but rather additional water content, leading to fuller muscles.
  • The change is temporary and will normalize once you stop taking creatine.
  • Staying well-hydrated can help manage this effect.

Understanding this aspect of creatine use is crucial. While the scale might show a higher number, remember, it’s primarily water, not added fat.

Featured product offer
Double Wood Supplements Creatine Powder
  • Micronized and unflavored creatine monohydrate.
  • 5g per serving may be taken with or without food.
  • Recommended dosage 3 to 5g per day.

2. Digestive issues

Digestive discomfort can be an unwanted guest when it comes to creatine supplementation. Some people might experience stomach pain, nausea, or diarrhea. This usually happens when large doses are consumed or if it’s taken without enough water or on an empty stomach.

  • It’s not uncommon for users to report stomach pain or discomfort.
  • Nausea and diarrhea can occur, especially if taken without adequate water or on an empty stomach.
  • Large doses tend to exacerbate these symptoms, so moderation is key.
  • To mitigate these issues, consider taking creatine with meals or trying micronized versions, which may be easier on the stomach.

Awareness of these potential side effects and adjusting your intake accordingly can help you enjoy the benefits of creatine without digestive distress.

3. Kidney concerns

You might’ve heard murmurs about creatine being hard on the kidneys. While there’s no conclusive evidence linking creatine to kidney damage in healthy individuals, if someone has pre-existing kidney issues, they should approach creatine with caution.

  • Prolonged intake of high creatine doses has raised concerns over kidney function.
  • Some believe that increased creatinine levels (a waste product) may suggest kidney strain [4].
  • However, most scientific studies have found no direct link between normal creatine use and kidney damage.
  • But, if you have existing kidney issues, it’s crucial to consult with a healthcare professional before starting supplementation.

It’s always wise to stay informed, monitor your health, and prioritize safe consumption habits.

potential for muscle cramps or strains
Photograph: wasant1/Envato

4. Potential for muscle cramps or strains

While some people praise creatine for reducing muscle discomfort, others report the opposite: muscle cramps or strains, especially when they’re dehydrated. Ensuring adequate hydration can possibly alleviate this concern.

  • Some users report experiencing muscle cramps, especially during intense workouts.
  • The exact cause remains a topic of debate, but dehydration might play a role.
  • Strains or pulls might also occur, potentially due to increased workout intensity inspired by the added energy from creatine.
  • To reduce these risks, ensure you stay hydrated and stretch adequately before and after exercise.

Remember, while these concerns exist, they don’t affect everyone. It’s all about finding the right balance and listening to your body.

5. Non-responders

Interestingly, not everyone reaps the benefits of creatine. A segment of the population might not see any noticeable changes in muscle size or performance, making the supplementation redundant for them. Genetics can play a role in how responsive you are to creatine.

  • Some individuals might not experience the typical benefits, such as increased muscle mass or enhanced exercise performance.
  • Factors like genetics, diet, and existing muscle creatine levels can influence one’s response.
  • For instance, vegetarians often see more significant benefits since their baseline creatine levels are usually lower.
  • On the other hand, someone with a meat-rich diet might not notice as much of a change.

Arming yourself with a well-rounded view of creatine can help you make choices tailored to your unique situation [5].

If you’re considering adding it to your routine, weigh the cons against the pros. And as always, when in doubt, seek guidance from healthcare professionals.

Final takeaways

Creatine has earned its spot as one of the most popular and well-researched supplements available today.

It offers a range of benefits, from boosting exercise performance and muscle growth to potentially supporting brain health.

But like all things, it’s essential to consider both its advantages and potential downsides. After all, supplements are just one piece of the puzzle.

A balanced diet, regular exercise, and a commitment to overall well-being will always be at the forefront of achieving optimal health.

Creatine, for many, can be a valuable tool in that toolkit, but it’s essential to approach its use thoughtfully and informed.


What are the pros and cons to taking creatine?

The pros of taking creatine include enhanced exercise performance, increased muscle mass, potential brain health benefits, and a generally safe profile for healthy individuals. However, some cons encompass water weight gain, potential digestive issues, concerns about kidney function with excessive use, and the possibility of muscle cramps or strains.

Is it necessary to do a ‘loading phase’ when starting creatine supplementation?

A loading phase can help saturate the muscles faster, but it’s not mandatory. Many people opt for a consistent daily dose without loading and still see benefits.

What happens when you stop creatine?

When you stop taking creatine, your body’s creatine phosphate stores will gradually decrease to natural levels over several weeks. As a result, the water retention and muscle volume associated with creatine supplementation may reduce, but the muscle gains achieved through training remain.

Is it good to just take creatine?

Taking creatine can offer benefits like improved exercise performance and muscle growth for many individuals. However, it’s essential to consider individual needs, potential side effects, and consult with a healthcare professional before starting supplementation.

Featured product offer
Naked Nutrition Creatine Monohydrate Powder 1KG
  • 100% pure, fast dissolving and rapidly absorbed creatine monohydrate.
  • No additives, soy, dairy or gluten. Non-GMO, vegan and keto-friendly.
  • Tested for heavy metals by independent 3rd-party.


Photograph: BLACKDAY/Envato
The information included in this article is for informational purposes only. The purpose of this webpage is to promote broad consumer understanding and knowledge of various health topics. It is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health care provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or treatment and before undertaking a new health care regimen, and never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.