Melatonin vs. herbal remedies: Which sleep supplements are safer and work best?

Tossing and turning at night isn’t just frustrating—it affects daily life, work, and health. Searching for a good night’s sleep has led many people to explore sleep supplements

Melatonin, a hormone naturally produced by the body, has gained immense popularity as an over-the-counter solution. Meanwhile, herbal remedies such as valerian root, chamomile, and lavender, with their historical roots and natural allure, continue to be a favorite for others seeking relief.

Before deciding which supplement to pick, it’s crucial to understand its unique characteristics. Melatonin is often used for short-term sleep problems like jet lag or adjusting to a new sleep schedule

It’s also available in various forms: pills, gummies, and liquid drops. However, while it’s widely used and considered generally safe, it can cause drowsiness, headaches, or nausea in some users.

Is melatonin actually effective?

Studies show that melatonin can be effective in addressing sleep issues, particularly those involving disruptions in circadian rhythm, such as jet lag or shift work disorder.

Melatonin supplements are frequently used to tackle various sleep disturbances, like jet lag or adjusting to new shift work schedules [1]. 

The role of melatonin in regulating the sleep-wake cycle makes it useful for helping people fall asleep faster and improve sleep quality, though results may vary based on the individual and their specific sleep problem.

For those dealing with insomnia, melatonin may shorten the time it takes to fall asleep and slightly increase total sleep duration. While results can vary, people often notice an improvement within a few days of consistent use.

Melatonin seems to offer the following benefits with relatively minor side effects:

  • Jet lag – Helps synchronize your sleep cycle to a new time zone, reducing fatigue and grogginess.
  • Shift work disorder – Assists in re-aligning sleep patterns for those working irregular hours.
  • Delayed sleep phase syndrome – Supports people who struggle to fall asleep until very late at night.

Despite its benefits, effectiveness largely depends on the individual’s specific sleep issue and adherence to proper dosage guidelines.

Melatonin usage guidelines
Photograph: enfocaydispara/Envato

Melatonin usage guidelines

Melatonin, a hormone that helps regulate sleep, is widely used as a supplement to address sleep disturbances like jet lag or irregular work shifts. Following proper guidelines ensures it’s taken safely and effectively for your specific needs.

ConditionDosageTimingNotes
Jet lagStart with 0.5-3 mgTake 30 minutes before bedtime in the new zoneContinue for a few days post-arrival
Shift work disorderStart with 1-3 mgTake 30 minutes before sleepUse consistently on work nights
InsomniaStart with 0.5-2 mgTake 30 minutes before bedtimeUse for at least 1-2 weeks consistently
Delayed sleep phaseStart with 0.5-3 mgTake 1-2 hours before the desired bedtimeMaintain a consistent sleep schedule
General sleep issuesStart with 0.5-1 mgTake 30 minutes before bedtimeGradually increase the dose if needed

If you’re pregnant, breastfeeding, or have existing health issues, consult your healthcare provider before using melatonin, especially if you take medications like blood thinners or antidepressants.

Meanwhile, if you experience significant side effects like dizziness, headaches, or stomach upset, try lowering your dose or stop taking it entirely.

Are there any negative side effects of melatonin?

Melatonin, while considered relatively safe for short-term use, can cause mild side effects for some individuals. These effects often include:

  • Drowsiness – Can linger into the morning or cause grogginess if the dose is too high [2].
  • Headache – A common complaint that may occur with melatonin use.
  • Dizziness – May make users feel lightheaded or unsteady.

Less common side effects include mild anxiety, stomach cramps, or irritability. Some people also report strange dreams or nightmares.

Melatonin isn’t intended as a long-term solution. It’s best used under guidance, especially for individuals with underlying health issues or those taking other medications.

How effective are herbal remedies?

Herbal remedies have long been used to promote sleep, and scientific studies increasingly reveal their potential efficacy.

The following table provides a quick reference to some common herbs, highlighting their uses, potential benefits, and considerations to keep in mind when using them as sleep aids.

HerbEffectivenessUsesNotes
Valerian rootMay shorten sleep onset and reduce anxietyMild insomnia, anxietyPotential side effects include dizziness and headaches
ChamomileCan improve sleep quality and reduce anxietyMild insomnia, stress reliefAllergic reactions possible in those sensitive to ragweed
LavenderPromotes relaxation through aromatherapyAnxiety, reducing sleep latencyApply topically with a carrier oil or diffuse for best results
PassionflowerPotentially increases sleep qualityAnxiety-related sleep disturbancesMild nausea or confusion may occur with higher doses
Lemon balmSoothes stress and anxietyGeneral relaxation, mild insomniaMost effective when combined with other herbs

Results can vary, and these herbs may not work equally well for everyone. Moreover, scientific data remains inconsistent, often due to variations in dosing, formulation, and individual responses.

Each herb offers unique benefits and requires specific usage guidelines to maximize its effectiveness safely.

Valerian root

  • Take 300-600 mg as a capsule or drink it as tea 30 minutes to an hour before bedtime.
  • Limit continuous use to a few weeks to avoid potential side effects.

Chamomile

  • Brew 2-3 grams of dried chamomile flowers in hot water to make tea [3].
  • Drink 30 minutes before bed for calming effects.

Lavender

  • Diffuse lavender essential oil in your bedroom to create a relaxing aroma.
  • Dilute lavender oil with a carrier oil and apply to your wrists or temples.

Passionflower

  • Drink as a tea or take 300-400 mg in capsule form 30 minutes before bed.
  • Avoid prolonged use, especially if you’re on medication for anxiety or depression.

Lemon balm

  • Combine lemon balm with other calming herbs like valerian root or chamomile for a synergistic effect.
  • Adjust dosages accordingly and monitor for any side effects like mild nausea or stomach upset.

What are the safety issues with herbal medicine?

Herbal remedies generally have a reputation for being gentle, but they can still cause side effects and require careful use.

Valerian root, for instance, might lead to dizziness, headaches, or stomach upset. Long-term use may have stronger effects, such as vivid dreams or even liver damage in rare cases.

Chamomile is widely recognized for its calming qualities, yet it may trigger allergic reactions in those sensitive to ragweed or related plants. Excessive use could also cause nausea or skin irritation [4].

Lavender, often applied topically or inhaled, has its own set of potential effects:

  • Topical – Skin irritation or allergic reactions in sensitive individuals.
  • Inhaled – Drowsiness, particularly when combined with other sedatives.

Passionflower is relatively mild but can occasionally lead to confusion, nausea, or a rapid heart rate.

Before trying these herbs, it’s wise to consult with a healthcare professional, especially if you’re pregnant, breastfeeding, or have an existing health condition. 

Herbal supplements may interact with prescription medications, amplifying or diminishing their effects. Like any sleep aid, herbal remedies should complement good sleep hygiene and be used thoughtfully for the best results.

What to consider when taking melatonin?
Photograph: ARTFULLY79/Envato

What to consider when taking melatonin?

When deciding between melatonin and herbal sleep supplements, weighing practical factors like availability, cost, and lifestyle fit is helpful. Understanding these aspects will ensure you choose a solution that matches your unique sleep needs and preferences.

Availability and accessibility

Melatonin and herbal remedies are easy to find, whether at pharmacies, health stores, or online. Melatonin comes in different forms like tablets, gummies, and liquid drops to suit personal preferences. 

Herbal sleep aids, such as valerian root and chamomile, are available as teas, tinctures, and capsules, offering various ways to incorporate them into your evening routine [5]. 

Lavender oil can be diffused or applied topically for a fragrant approach. Regardless of your choice, there’s a suitable option for everyone seeking better sleep.

Lifestyle and preferences

Melatonin is perfect for those who appreciate convenience and precision, offering a quick, measurable way to aid sleep. For those drawn to natural health solutions, herbal remedies like chamomile tea or lavender oil provide a sensory experience that enhances relaxation. 

Whether you prefer the simplicity of a pill or the ritual of brewing herbal tea, there’s a sleep solution to fit your nightly routine. Each option caters to different habits, helping you find the best path to a restful night.

Quality and safety

Quality matters when choosing melatonin or herbal supplements for sleep. To guarantee purity and precise dosage, look for trustworthy companies that employ independent testing [6]. 

Avoid brands that make exaggerated claims or lack clear labeling. To measure your body’s reaction and reduce any side effects, start with the lowest dose that is advised.

Consider the plant’s origin for herbal products, as some regions may have different cultivation standards. Always consult a healthcare professional before starting new supplements, especially if you’re taking medications or have pre-existing health conditions.

In closing

When choosing between melatonin and herbal remedies, finding the right sleep aid depends on your unique needs and preferences.

Melatonin, a hormone supplement, is ideal for a quick and effective option to address jet lag, shift work, or temporary sleep disturbances. It provides consistent dosing, but you should start with a low dose and gradually adjust.

Ultimately, better sleep starts with knowing yourself and what works for your routine. Take the time to experiment with these options thoughtfully, and don’t hesitate to contact healthcare professionals for guidance. With the right supplement and practices, you’ll be well on your way to more restful nights.

FAQs

Do herbal remedies have any side effects?

Herbal remedies can cause mild side effects like dizziness or stomach upset. Allergic reactions may occur in people sensitive to specific plants like ragweed.

Can I take melatonin if I’m on other medications?

Melatonin may interact with certain medications, such as blood thinners or antidepressants. Speak with your healthcare provider before adding melatonin to your routine.

How long does it take for herbal sleep aids to work?

Effects vary, but most people experience relaxation within 30-60 minutes. Consistent use over several days often provides more noticeable benefits.

Can children use melatonin or herbal remedies safely?

Children can use melatonin or herbal remedies, but only under the guidance of a healthcare provider. Dosage and potential side effects must be carefully considered.

[1] https://www.sleepfoundation.org/melatonin
[2] https://www.healthline.com/health/drowsiness
[3] https://simpleseasonal.com/how-to/how-to-make-chamomile-tea-with-fresh-flowers
[4] https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/agricultural-and-biological-sciences/chamomile
[5] https://www.healthline.com/health/healthy-sleep/natural-sleep-aids
[6] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5263069/

Photograph: Olena_Rudo/Envato
The information included in this article is for informational purposes only. The purpose of this webpage is to promote broad consumer understanding and knowledge of various health topics. It is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health care provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition or treatment and before undertaking a new health care regimen, and never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website.